Why three votes for Second Vice President?

This year’s annual business meeting (Saturday, Aug. 14, 2010) went on for more than four hours, almost entirely due to the time required to count votes, most especially for holding two extra votes for Second Vice President.

There’s an easy solution to this.  Well, two solutions:

  1. Move to an electronic voting method.
  2. Use preferential voting.

The electronic voting can be done in many different ways, but I would recommend a solution similar to how many states hold elections today, with an optical scan voting system, where the voters fill in a bubble or connect a line on a paper ballot to indicate their preferences.  This process is simple, requires no expensive electronics in the voters’ hands, and can be easily audited afterward.

Preferential voting is the key though, and it’s something we already use — for speech contests!  Speech contest judges mark their first three choices, and tie-breakers rank all the contestants.  We can do the same thing in our elections, especially with electronic vote counting.  When a “re-vote” is needed, the computer ballot scanner can do so automatically (and instantaneously), ignoring the dropped candidate.  (You could do preferential vote counting by hand, but it would be laborious, having to examine each ballot and skip any dropped candidates for the voter’s next choice.)

With the International Leadership Committee (ILC) from Global Representation and Support bringing us more and more qualified candidates, multiple re-votes will be more and more common.  Without these improvements, we’ll face  interminable business meetings, waiting for results and then voting yet again on the candidates.  Putting these steps in place will also allow the ILC (and RLCs?) to be more comfortable with presenting the voters with three choices to consider, instead of just two.

By simplifying the election process to a single ballot, we might even achieve Parliamentarian Herb Nowlin’s dream of an election with no spoiled or illegal ballots!

Saturday morning: Business meeting

Was quite interesting, THREE ballots for Second VP!  It didn’t wrap up until 11:30, after several breaks while the ballots were counted.

Second Vice President, first ballot:
Ralph Wallace, 5,673
George Yen, 4,545
Bash Turay, 3,636
John Rich, 3,499

Second ballot:
Ralph Wallace, 6,843
George Yen, 6,087
Bash Turay, 3,972

Third ballot:
George Yen, 9,365
Ralph Wallace, 7.801

Region 2:
Kevin Doyle, 10,810
Debra Ledsinger, 6,629

Region 4:
Jacqueline Schnider, 12,795
Patricia Hannan, 4,628

Region 6:
Gina Cook, 13,733
John MacDonald, 3,652

Region 8:
David Hollingshead, 10,581
Patricia Gann, 6,749

Region 10:
Roberta Perry, 14,710
Lois Sicking, 2,704

Region 12:
Mike Storkey (uncontested)

Region 14:
Gea Ban Peng, 12,048
Adelina Cuizon Roya, 5,392